Critics say the straight-to-streaming film about coach John Madden can't decide what story it's trying to tell.
Madden, the new biopic about legendary coach John Madden, dropped on Amazon Prime Wednesday, and the reaction from critics has been rough. The film opens near the end of Madden's tenure as head coach of the Oakland Raiders in 1977, a stretch where he was under pressure to finally win a Super Bowl after four straight seasons of playoff flameouts. Reviewers say that setup gets abandoned almost immediately, with the movie rushing through the AFC Championship game that follows.
Beyond the pacing problems, critics describe the film as a loosely connected string of nostalgic moments rather than a coherent story about Madden's life. One review called it a CliffsNotes-style fever dream that seems uninterested in both its subject and its audience, despite coming from Amazon MGM and director David O. Russell. Another critic suggested the chaotic style points to a movie that was hoping to be fixed in editing, only for the editing itself to fail to make sense of the material.
Not every take has been entirely dismissive. At least one review argues that while the film is as messy as advertised, there may still be reasons to watch it, even if it never approaches the quality of classic sports movies like Hoosiers or The Natural.