Back 1 / 40 brokenews
Photo from Axios accompanying coverage of this story

US seeks new charges against former FBI chief James Comey

What every side agrees happened

The Justice Department has charged former FBI Director James Comey for a third time, this time accusing him of illegally disclosing national defense information connected to a 2016 leak to a New York Times reporter. Comey has denied the allegations.

The charges were filed as a criminal information rather than through a grand jury indictment. Fox News reported the government's defense of this method, quoting officials who said, "Filing a criminal information to toll the statute of limitations is a widely recognized practice in federal court and has been approved by multiple Circuit Courts of Appeals. This is an ongoing criminal investigation, and we will not comment further."1

Questions have been raised about whether the case falls outside the applicable time limit. BBC News reported that former federal prosecutor Glenn Kirschner told the outlet the case may have exceeded the 10 year statute of limitations, giving a motion to dismiss "a very good chance of being granted."2

The Guardian (US) reported that legal experts have said the case is thin.

HuffPost reported on evidence described in the investigation, stating that the investigation has uncovered evidence that Comey directed staff to speak to Mr. Savage about specific accuracy concerns related to the Reuters article, and thereby illegally transferred classified information.

The announcement coincided with a ruling related to the firing of Maurene Comey.

Written by brokenews from 12 sources across the spectrum · Machine-drafted, verified against every source · Methodology →

Lawyer explains why Trump's DOJ wants to charge ex-FBI head James Comey right now · Face the Nation on YouTube · Watch on YouTube

How each side told it

Coverage split 25 · 33 · 42
Left 3 sources

Justice Dept. Brings More Charges Against Comey, Accusing Him of Leaks

The Guardian and NYT emphasize the political context of Trump's long-running animus toward Comey, describe the case as a 'criminal maneuver' to beat the statute of limitations, note that legal experts call the parallel '86 47' case 'thin', and frame the repeated prosecutions as part of a pattern of DOJ action against 'Trump's most despised foes.'

The New York Times $ paywall

Straight, sourced Read at The New York Times →
Center 4 sources

James Comey charged again by the DOJ

Centrist outlets (Axios, CNBC, BBC, DW) report the new charges as a straightforward legal/political development, emphasizing procedural details (criminal information vs. indictment, statute of limitations dispute), Comey's history of prior charges, his denial, and the coincidental timing with the ruling on Maurene Comey's firing.

Axios

Straight, sourced Read at Axios →
Right 5 sources

James Comey faces new DOJ case over alleged national defense disclosure

Right-leaning outlets (Daily Wire, Washington Times, Fox News, Daily Caller, Breitbart) report the charges with detailed procedural specifics from DOJ filings (the Farahnak filing, Reuters correction angle) and include the DOJ's own defense of using a criminal information to toll the statute of limitations, with Breitbart additionally citing AG Todd Blanche defending the related '86 47' indictment as based on more than just the Instagram post.

Fox News

Straight, sourced Read at Fox News →

Notes & sources

12 sources · 12 articles
Skip the source list ↓
← Back to today
NextBrazilian leftist President Lula wins reelection against conservative challenger Flavio Bolsonaro